
Visual inspection of cooling boxes for pharmaceutical and food industry
Basis for efficient and sustainable recycling processes

Our customer eutecma GmbH is a leading manufacturer of cooling solutions for the transport of temperature-sensitive products in the food and pharmaceutical sectors. Through its retecma division, the Mannheim-based company is implementing the world's first recycling cycle for modular cooling boxes in sizes from 4 litres to 1588 litres.
These EPS (expanded polystyrene) boxes are equipped with RFID chips that give each component a unique identity including type, weight and number of recycling cycles. Used or no longer required boxes can be returned to special "refreshment centres" where they enter a cycle that guarantees their reuse.
At these refreshment centres, they are scanned on arrival and automatically registered in the system. The boxes are then weighed to identify any missing material and then checked using a camera system and artificial intelligence. If the box is OK, it is then irradiated with UV light, evaporated and returned to the cycle. If a box does not meet the specified weight or if the optical inspection detects a defect or damage, the damaged component is sorted out and sent to an appropriate recycling process.
Machine vision ensures circular economy
This is where phil-vision comes into play. In one system, a camera system measures the returned boxes, which consist of several modules, compares them with the corresponding 3D models and checks the outer shell for damage. This is all in the interests of sustainability, as the transport containers checked in this way can be reused more than 15 times under optimum conditions, provided that they are not damaged.
What makes the task so challenging is the fact that the boxes do not arrive at the test facility unmixed, but wildly mixed up. However, upstream processes ensure that the control system recognises the current model and can load the appropriate 3D data. The difficulty, however, lies in capturing the different sizes and achieving sufficient resolution on a measurement volume of varying sizes.
After initial experiments with ToF/LIDAR technology, the final decision was made to use stereo cameras. According to project manager Markus Kirstein, a key advantage of stereo cameras in combination with pattern projectors is the high degree of flexibility with regard to the materials to be analysed. When asked about the main challenges for the vision system, Kirstein cites durability, reliability, performance and repeatability.

Stereo cameras for flexible detection and high accuracy

The sensor head used for the visual inspection consists of five stereo heads with 20MP GigE cameras, which are mounted at a distance of 1550 mm from the transport rollers, covering an area of approximately 200x160 cm and capturing the boxes four times from above at an angle and once straight from above.
This data is used to create a 3D image, which is then compared to the corresponding CAD model. The calculations are performed on an IPC that is connected via ProfiNET.
The cameras are connected via the GigE Vision interface and calibrated and reconstructed using Halcon image processing software. The matching and checking of the point distances to the matched model is carried out in a software component developed in-house.
Another difficulty in the application is distinguishing between main defects pseudo defects and artefacts, as well as possible material deviations. If the material deviates significantly from the CAD, it can be very difficult to find defects.
Checking for smallest damages
The system currently inspects boxes for dents and chips > 5mm. For this reason, high accuracy is extremely important. Defects are initially detected using a defect algorithm as basis for future categorisation and the use of artificial intelligence.
If defects are not detected correctly, defective parts can pass as "OK" or good parts can be categorised as "not OK", which can distort material flows and lead to customer complaints.

Cooperation and partnership for maximum performance
The collaboration with phil-vision started in summer 2022 after several discussions with a feasibility study and subsequent component selection and now includes the integration, calibration, point-cloud generation and IPC communication via ProfiNET. The partnership has resulted in a solution that has been in productive use since May 2024.
Patrick Gailer, responsible Project Manager at phil-vision summarises the challenges of the application as follows:
The system has to work fast and detect the position of the points in a large measuring field with high resolution. This is where our stereo head solutions prove themselves once again. phil-vision’s very flexible stereo camera technology allows it to precisely adapt the required resolution and viewing angles to the application. The customer receives fully calibrated stereo camera heads that can be "merged" into a point cloud after a simple calibration process. The "objects" in the point cloud remain extremely dimensionally accurate, even over large measurement fields, so that the data can be compared to CAD data or "golden samples". In this application, the density of the points is reduced locally to reduce processing time. Global dimensional accuracy is maintained.
Another major advantage of stereo cameras is the fact that instead of the point cloud 2D images can also be used for processing or AI. As the 2D images are also calibrated, it is possible to switch seamlessly between 3D and 2D for processing. This provides enormous flexibility, as all other information such as contrast and colour can be used at full resolution in addition to the depth information.
Assuming that a "Cold Chain Protect Box" is reused 15 times, approximately 1,000 kilograms of CO2 can be saved. The retecma cycle also ensures that not a single gram of polystyrene (expanded polystyrene EPS) is lost. Artificial intelligence, regional logistics and high-quality recycling enables eutecma’s customers to reduce their emissions and make their supply chains more sustainable, as the boxes can be reprocessed or recycled in an environmentally friendly way directly in the region, if required. The modular system allows only damaged components to be replaced if necessary.
eutecma GmbH
eutecma develops modular, sustainable and innovative cooling solutions for a safe and efficient cold chain. The products haven proven themselves at numerous customers time and time again. And this makes them the first choice for pharmaceutical and food companies. The people behind eutecma make sure that several million ICECATCH cooling elements and the corresponding PROTECT boxes leave the factory halls in Mannheim every year.
More interesting application stories
You are looking for a customised solution?
We are happy to discuss your ideas and requirements in detail and work with you to develop a bespoke solution to meet your specific needs.